13 years after the murder, in 2002, a new prosecutor took a look at this cold case and decided to open it up again so as to charge Jeff with four counts of murder, even with no new evidence. Jeff Pelley was convicted of the murders in 2006 and is serving a 160-year prison sentence. Where Is Jeff Pelley Today? Seventeen years later, Jessi’s stepbrother Jeff Pelley was convicted of the homicides. https://mycrimelibrary.com/jeff-pelley-teen-killer-prom-night-murders By this time, Jeff had relocated to Florida. You can see Jim's full report -- including new insight from investigators -- and Jeff Pelley's stepsister, now known as Jessi. In the book, Toronjo says that her childhood ended the day of the murders. He was happily married, had a son, and was working as a computer consultant at IBM.